**>>>You can view the stats by clicking this link which takes you to a Google spreadsheet<<<**

So based on this, we can see the important info. It's not about the individuals, it's about each army's win rate as a whole.

If we take all these player's records and combine them, then we get overall win rates of:

USA win rate: 61.96%

British win rate: 63.88%

Wehrmacht win rate: 57.00%

Panzer Elite win rate: 56.01%

However, these stats are not completely truthful. Many of these players have games from vCoH, others only play 1 or 2 armies, and others are influenced by noob stomping where that player would win no matter what. It just gives a very rough idea of what the overall picture looks like. In other words, these numbers are unreliable.