1- The panzer D kills with one shot (75 mm short)
Can you click this link plz?
https://youtu.be/4B9PJEOIChA?t=1653The link will deliver you exactly at minute 27:33 on this video.
Now, watch carefully what happened after I simply flanked the JagdPanzer and killed it (Hetzer can also die the same way) and then look how my Comet bounced off Panzer.D which has short 75mm gun!
After that my Comet was penetrated by 76 for sure, which is not a problem though...
So, are you sure the Panzer.D can penetrate and kill Comet?
I also made a test few days ago... Short barrel 75mm (Puma 75, Panzer.D, Panzer.E) CAN'T penetrate Comet reliably from the front. 50mm bounces often enough, and long barrel 75mm bounce only sometimes.
2-The Panther "G" no costs three times more than the comet, adds the MP!
I was more speaking about the fuel price, but if you add the MP price too.. then 2 Comet = 120 fuel and 940 MP and 6 CP.
Panther.G costs 7 CP, 155 fuel and 890 MP. 2 Comet can kill the Panther, but can also kill a King Tiger (200 fuel) or Tiger1 (170 fuel) so it's still fair.
And u will need 2 Comet vs King Tiger, and not 2 Firefly because Firefly can't really penetrate King Tiger from the front and doesn't have flank speed, but Comet has flank speed.
3-The Stug 3 maintains HE and is very good with the mg42
But no speed, less chance to escape... Speed is a vital advantage, don't underestimate the superiority of high speed.
Comet can shoot HE and escape.. and actually not just HE, you can also shoot tanks with AP and escape quickly! Your weak armor will not be a problem if your enemy won't catch or hit you in the first place, and btw... Comet is harder to hit, which means most enemy guns will miss more often vs Comet than vs Stug, Panther, or anything else.
honestly most of the shots of the AT squad go to the ground (I do not know why), so I do not know what you're talking about
Stug dies with 2 Bazookas. It's me who is not sure what you are talking about here! o.O
Well, unless you are unlucky for sure and your rockets hit the ground.. but this can happen with Shrecks too! But even if you hit the ground.. at least you had the time to shoot the Stug, but with PanzerShrecks you will not even have time to shoot the Comet, because it will escape in few seconds thanks to the very high speed.
4- The comet does not work and using 6 CP for this unit is not such a good idea
Come on my friend
76 Jumbo cost 7 command points, has much more armor.. but limit to 1 only.
For 6 CP, you can have Comet which has better gun, better HE and better speed + 3 limit (it might be unlimited in the future though) and it WORKS!
5- This repetition only shows that your enemies are rusted, it is not a good example
Teams were balanced, don't disregard the Axis players who played against us.. in fact, everyone of them is probably better than you!
I say probably ^^
6-I want to see the comet escape from the Hetzer
If I use your logic here, then I could also say:
I want to see Pz4.H escape from Achilles...
Achilles can snipe Pz.4.H from a long range with hit and run tactics ability. And the Panzer4.H in TH doctrine is more expensive than Comet, it costs 80 fuel. If you don't have enough ammo to use the hit and run ability, you can use ur speed.. which means you can also flank the Panzer4.H or shoot it from the front and quickly run away.
7- You compare the British units a lot with those of WM, apparently you forget PE, which It has 67283727171 ways to kill this weak comet
Every unit PE has which can kill Comet, the Comet can kill it too...
Hetzer can easily kill you? Well, you can easily kill it too.
JagdPanther (180 fuel or 160 after unlock) can kill you? You can flank with 2 Comet and kill him too. Panther.D also same...
JagdTiger? Well, flank him with 3 Comet and kick his ass! You can't flank him with 3 Firefly...
8- When you speak of Spam de comet, it seems as if the British had infinite MP, keep the British troop has its cost
Look, a tank such as the KT can always penetrate and kill Comet maybe even in 1 shot, even when Comet had better armor before the changes!
Now, answer this question.. if you need 3 Comets to kill a King Tiger because you can't really do the same with 3 Firefly, what would u prefer to pay?
(NOW) 3 Comets (180 fuel - 1410 MP) vs 1 KT (200 fuel - 1200 MP)
OR
(PAST) 3 Comets (300 fuel - 1950 MP) vs 1 KT (200 fuel - 1200 MP)
Keeping in mind you die with 1 shot in both cases. What is better then? First option OF COURSE.
you are practically telling me to kill comets, with KT or Panthers, while the most logical would be to use hetzers, Stug or more mobile units, not to mention that these units could already have veteran, when the comet arrives, where finally you realize that the comet, It's not a big deal
Same way for Axis... You don't have to kill Tigers with Pershing! It could be more logical to do it with Hellcat or M10 Wolverine, and oh by the way... M10 Wolverine can kill Tiger1, Stug can't kill Pershing. Not to mention that when 1 Tiger for nearly 170 fuel finally arrive after 5 Command Points, your tank destroyers can be already veteran too.. so the Tiger tank won't be a big deal either.
HOPE you get the point now...